Home › Blog › Current Post

A Used Pallet Sells for $14.91. Its Plastic Is Worth $13.80.

The price ceiling for a moulded recycled pallet is not set by another pallet maker. It is set by a used pallet yard and by a grinder.

Here is the whole argument in one line. A buyer with a load to move has three options. He can buy a new moulded pallet, buy a used one, or sell the plastic he already owns. Whichever of those three numbers is cheapest sets what everybody else can charge. When two of the three converge, the market changes shape. That is what happened this month.

What decides a moulded pallet’s price ceiling: the lowest credible alternative a buyer has at the moment of purchase. Today that alternative is a used pallet at roughly the scrap value of the plastic in it. Any new pallet priced above the used band has to sell something the used band cannot supply. Price alone will not do it.

The two numbers that touched

Repackify’s US index printed $14.91 for a used 48×40×6 in plastic pallet on 18 November (price index). Chinese recyclers quoted ¥4,000–4,500 per tonne for clean HDPE pallet scrap on 15 November (scrap quotes). At 23 kg, and around ¥7.1 to the dollar, that scrap is worth $13 to $14.60. Call it $13.80 at the middle of the range.

Two numbers, one from a resale marketplace and one from a weighbridge in Henan, landed inside a dollar of each other. That gap used to be the used pallet trade. It was once $6 to $8 wide. Now it is a rounding error. A rounding error does not pay for a yard, a forklift and a salesman.

Read the same index carefully and you find a second problem. The headline average is $6.47, with a typical range of $4.05 to $8.01. The same page lists “new” at $67.50. Those figures describe a 4 kg nestable and a 30 kg rackable in the same bucket. Averages across incomparable products are useless for procurement. Use the size and load print, which is why the 48×40 number matters and the $6.47 does not.

The floor is the flake, and the flake is not all equal

Sorting decides what your spent pallet is worth. Clean HDPE pallet scrap fetches ¥4,000–4,500 a tonne. Mixed-colour PE goes for ¥2,000–3,000. Add glass-filled compounds or steel inserts and the quote drops to ¥1,600–2,400, because somebody has to cut the metal out by hand.

For a moulder this is the first lesson in feedstock discipline. A pallet designed with removable steel reinforcement keeps its scrap value at the end of life. One with steel cast into the ribs turns a $13 asset into a $5 to $7 one. You decide that in the mould drawing, not in the scrap yard.

The second lesson is about competition for the same material. Since 21 November, plastic waste exports from the EU to non-OECD countries have been closed, which leaves bales inside Europe. Regenport’s week-three report shows European LDPE bale prices falling hard as the shipping window shut. Natural rHDPE pellet prices firmed in the same week, while rPP stayed the weakest of the polyolefins (market report). Cheap bales look like good news for a compression line. They also mean every compounder in Europe is now bidding for the same clean flake you want for pallets.

Why the yard empties out

When resale equals flake, the rational move for the yard is to grind. Grinding needs no grading, no shrink wrap and no customer who returns thirty pallets because two are cracked. So the good used stock leaves the trade and the remainder gets worse. Buyers then find that the cheap channel offers only three things. They get pallets with eleven years of service, mismatched heights, and no load history.

This is not a prediction about 2030. It is the arithmetic of this quarter. The spread between like-new and used grades on the index already shows it.

Where your landed cost actually comes from

Most feasibility models start with press tonnage. That is the wrong end. Start with finished pallet weight, because weight drives material, cycle time and freight all at once.

Take a 23 kg pallet in the heavy export class. Allow 8% process scrap and 3% handling loss, so the press eats about 24 kg per good pallet. At $420 a tonne for dirty mixed feedstock that is $10.10 of material. At $600 a tonne for clean flake it is $14.40. Add 2 to 3.5 kWh at $0.18 and you have 40 to 60 cents of power. Conversion, meaning labour, mould amortisation and the 13 to 16 cents of wear cost per pallet, adds $2.50 to $3.

Landed cost: $13 to $18.

Now take a 13 kg pallet in the same footprint. Input drops to about 14 kg, material falls to $5.90 on dirty feedstock, and the same conversion applies. Landed cost: $9 to $12. Every kilogram you take out of the design removes roughly 45 cents of material. It also removes another 55 to 60 cents of finished cost.

That is the entire argument for weight discipline. A line building 23 kg pallets at $15 cannot beat a used pallet at $14.91 on price. The same line building 13 kg pallets at $10 clears the ceiling with room to spare.

None of that means light is always right. A 13 kg pallet needs the rib and leg geometry to carry the load. The load class is a safety decision made against ISO 8611, not a cost decision. Our own trial data on the heavy class shows the other end of the range. It held 23 kg in a 60-second cycle, with 2,000 kg dynamic and 6,000 kg static on a 1,300 × 1,100 mm footprint. The plastic pallet machine line is specified around which of those two classes you intend to sell.

The one thing a used yard cannot sell

Paperwork. Under PPWR Article 15, a reusable pallet in the EU has to carry a type, batch or serial identifier. It also has to carry the manufacturer’s name and address. The technical file stays with the producer. A used yard can stamp its own name on a repaired pallet. It cannot reconstruct which polymer went into a pallet moulded in 2019 by a company that has since closed.

That gap widens from 2030, when the recycled-content floor and the A to E recyclability grades bite. It also matters at the tender desk right now. Procurement teams under the EmpCo rules on green claims need evidence, and “we think it is HDPE” is not evidence. This is why we cut the batch code into the cavity rather than stencilling it afterwards, a decision we walked through in the PPWR marking guide.

There is a third route for anyone who wants a distinctive footprint rather than a commodity one. Custom rib layouts and pattern changes cost a mould, not a new press. The pattern library shows what buyers ask for once they stop shopping on price alone.

Three lines for your next RFQ

Put the finished weight and the load class on the first line, and tonnage on the second. A 1,600-tonne press and an 800-tonne press can both run a 13 kg pallet. The difference is cycle time and how much mould you can carry, not the quality of the part.

Ask for cost per pallet at your own tariff and your own feedstock price, with moisture and reject rate stated. Brochure figures assume clean flake and cheap power, and both assumptions fail in most of the world.

Ask which cavity carries the identifier, and what the maintenance schedule looks like at 250,000 shots. A single-station layout suits one heavy product. A dual-station press pays back when you need two sizes on one floor. Either way, wear parts belong in the capex sheet from day one, not in year two.

The ceiling will not rise

Every year the used pallet gets closer in price to the plastic it contains. That pressure does not reverse, because the material has other buyers and the resale yard has fewer.

So the two levers left are weight and evidence. Cut the part down to the load it must carry. Then prove what it is made of, in a way a buyer can file. Everything else is a story about tonnage.

If you want to test the arithmetic on your own feedstock, our engineers will run your material through a mould and weigh the result. Send a sample through the contact page and we will quote a cycle, a pallet weight and a cost per unit against this year’s prices.

Request a Quote

Please submit your question. Our team will contact you within 24 hours.